Free Family Phone Plan

Research

The research behind our videos.

We read the studies so you don't have to, and we try to be honest about what they do and don't show. That's why you'll hear us say "linked" and "odds," not "causes." Most of this research can show that two things go together. It usually can't prove that one causes the other.

Two phones charging on a hallway shelf at night outside a child's bedroom door, with a cat asleep nearby
Kids with their own smartphone
  • Age 1042%
  • Age 1271%

Source: Common Sense Census, 2021 (published 2022)

71% of 12-year-olds in a national survey had their own smartphone

How many kids have a smartphone, and when?

Common Sense Media (2022). The Common Sense Census: Media Use by Tweens and Teens, 2021. Survey of 1,306 U.S. 8- to 18-year-olds, conducted September–October 2021; report published March 9, 2022. commonsensemedia.org

Source
Common Sense Media
Year
2022
Who
1,306 U.S. kids, ages 8 to 18

In plain language

  • 42% of 10-year-olds had their own smartphone.

  • 71% of 12-year-olds did.

  • About 9 in 10 kids aged 14 and older had one.

What it means for parents: A phone between 10 and 12 is common, but “common” describes what families do, not a recommendation. If you want to wait, it helps to decide early and find other families.

Play-based to phone-based: the book at the center of the debate

The Anxious Generation

Haidt, J. (2024). The Anxious Generation: How the Great Rewiring of Childhood Is Causing an Epidemic of Mental Illness. New York: Penguin Press. Published March 26, 2024. anxiousgeneration.com

Source
Jonathan Haidt, Penguin Press
Year
2024
Who
A social psychologist’s argument

In plain language

  • Haidt argues childhood shifted from “play-based” to “phone-based” in the early 2010s.

  • He sees that shift as a major reason teen anxiety and depression rose so sharply.

  • 4 new norms No smartphones before high school, no social media before 16, phone-free schools, and far more independence and free play.

Our take: We love the play part; it’s where the name Wild Not Wired comes from. The title says “causing,” and many researchers think the evidence is weaker than that, so we don’t use that word. See the review below.

Does waiting matter? Young adults reporting serious suicidal thoughts, by age at first smartphone
  • Women · first phone at 5–648%
  • Women · first phone at 1328%
  • Men · first phone at 5–631%
  • Men · first phone at 1320%

What this means for you: each year closer to 13 was linked to better outcomes as a young adult.

If your teen is struggling, call or text 988 (Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, U.S.).

Source: Sapien Labs, J. Human Development & Capabilities (2025). “Serious” = rated 7+ on a 9-point scale; self-reported

A later first smartphone is linked to better mental health as a young adult

Getting a smartphone later is linked to better mental health as a young adult

Thiagarajan, T. C., Newson, J. J., & Swaminathan, S. (2025). Protecting the developing mind in a digital age: A global policy imperative. Journal of Human Development and Capabilities, 26(3), 493–504. Sapien Labs, Global Mind Project. doi.org/10.1080/19452829.2025.2518313

Source
Sapien Labs, J. Human Development & Capabilities
Year
2025
Who
100,000+ young adults aged 18–24, worldwide

In plain language

  • 100,000+ young adults aged 18–24 worldwide reported when they got their first smartphone and how they’re doing now.

  • 48% vs. 28% of young women reported serious suicidal thoughts if their first phone came at 5–6 vs. at 13 (men: 31% vs. 20%). Low self-worth, aggression and feeling detached from reality followed the same pattern.

  • A big share of the link ran through early social media, cyberbullying, disrupted sleep and poorer family relationships, so those are good places to focus at any age.

Keep in mind: The data is self-reported and correlational, so it shows a link, not proof of cause, and the authors say so. Some outside experts have also questioned the study’s methods.

The skeptic’s view: social media links are small and mixed

“The great rewiring”: a skeptical review

Odgers, C. L. (2024). The great rewiring: is social media really behind an epidemic of teenage mental illness? Nature, 628(8006), 29–30. doi.org/10.1038/d41586-024-00902-2

Source
Candice Odgers, Nature
Year
2024
Who
A developmental psychologist’s critical review

In plain language

  • Odgers argues the evidence doesn’t show social media is rewiring kids’ brains or causing a mental-health epidemic; many studies find small or mixed associations.

  • She worries blaming phones could distract from other causes, like poverty, discrimination and a lack of mental-health care.

  • She agrees platforms need serious reform, and thinks age-based bans may not work well in practice.

Why we include it: Because you deserve the whole picture, not just the half that agrees with us.

Not everyone agrees, and that's okay.

Researchers are still arguing about how much smartphones and social media are behind the rise in teen anxiety and depression. Some, like Haidt, see a major cause. Others, like Odgers, say the evidence is weak or mixed. Large studies like the Sapien Labs one find strong links, but links aren't proof.

Here's where we land. Waiting on a smartphone costs a family very little. More play, more sleep and more face-to-face friendship are good for kids no matter which side of the debate turns out to be right. So we'd rather give childhood the benefit of the doubt.

Spotted something we got wrong? Tell us at hello@wildnotwired.com and we'll fix it.